Note: Lineup subject to change due to weather and released MLB lineups. Check back before contest lineups lock for our final lineup.
C: Hidden
1B: Albert Pujols (LAA) vs. C. Sabathia (NYY) — $4,400
2B: Hidden
3B: Nolan Arenado (COL) @ K. Graveman (OAK) — $5,200
SS: Troy Tulowitzki (COL) @ K. Graveman (OAK) — $4,700
OF: Mike Trout (LAA) vs. C. Sabathia (NYY) — $4,900
OF: Charlie Blackmon (COL) @ K. Graveman (OAK) — $4,900
OF: Chris Young (NYY) @ C. Wilson (LAA) — $3,500
SP: Jimmy Nelson (MIL) @ S. O’Sullivan (PHI) — $6,600
SP: Hidden
Today I’m going back to the same well that’s left me thirsty many times over the past few weeks — starting a pitcher against the Phillies. Yes, Philadelphia’s offense has a good K rate that makes high-strikeout games harder to come by. Yes, Maikel Franco’s hot streak has added an element of fear to the lineup that the team had previously lacked. No, I’m not letting a few recent bumps dissuade me from making what I believe is a good upside selection.
As explained in the comment’s section of last Friday’s post, over a recent 10-game stretch the Phillies offense had allowed the opposing SP to exceed their season average DraftKings points in nine of 10 games with an overall boost of 30%. A big reason was Philadelphia’s inability to win games, handing the opposing SP a four-point win. Plus, they’re just not good at scoring runs (a few recent outbursts aside) and every run prevented is as good as one strikeout.
Let’s do some math in an attempt to figure out just how much Philadelphia’s horrible offense (and team in general) cancels out their ability to make a decent amount of contact.
Consider Philadelphia’s K% over the last two weeks, 18.6%. That’s 14th-lowest in the league over that span, and nearly identical to their 18.5% mark over the last 30 days, which itself ranks 22nd-highest. Regardless of the rank, the number itself is pretty stable — 18.5%. This season Nelson has averaged 25.5 batters faced per game with a 19.6 K% that’s only a touch under the league average of 20.1%. For the sake of simplicity, let’s just call Nelson a league average strikeout pitcher. Against the Phillies, a league average strikeout pitcher would fan 4.74 batters per start, which of course would be 4.74 DraftKings points. Against a league average strikeout offense, a league average pitcher would fan 5.13 batters per start, or 5.13 DraftKings points.
More math. Over the last 30 days the Phillies have scored 92 runs in 26 games, or 3.54 runs per game. Nelson has average 6 IP per start this season, so we’ll attribute two-thirds of those 3.54 runs to him. That’s 2.37 runs allowed (ignoring the difference between runs and earned runs), or -2.37 DraftKings points. A league average offense over the last 30 days has scored 4.08 runs per game, two-thirds of which we’re attributing to the SP — 2.73 runs or -2.73 DraftKings Points.
Still more math. Let’s look at those pesky -0.60 point subtractions a pitcher gets for allowing a baserunner. Well, the Phillies have a .292 OBP over the last month, which means 7.45 of those 25.5 batters faced will reach base. That’s -4.47 DraftKings points. The league average OBP over the last 30 days is .316, or -4.83 DraftKings Points.
This is the last math. Wins are a little harder to quantify, at least as far as projecting the likelihood of a starting pitcher earning one, so for that I’m going to take the following approach:
- Vegas lines represent the likelihood of a particular team winning any given game
- Starting pitchers earn 70% of all decisions, which has been the case this season
Behind the scenes (to save words) I performed this same analysis again, this time using the Cubs high-strikeout offense in place of the Phillies. The results are compiled below. (Note that for the Wins analysis I used the May 3 Brewers at Cubs game in which Nelson faced Jason Hammel. The Brewers closed at +135 to win with the Cubs at -145.)
| Stat | Phillies | Cubs | Lg Avg Off. |
| Ks | 4.74 | 5.64 | 5.13 |
| Runs | -2.37 | -2.60 | -2.73 |
| H+BB | -4.47 | -4.94 | -4.83 |
| Wins | 1.65 | 1.15 | 1.40 |
| Outs | 13.50 | 12.95 | 13.08 |
| Total | 13.05 | 12.20 | 12.05 |
For “Outs” above, I just kept it simple and calculated those points as the following: (25.5 Batters Faced) – (Number of Baserunners) = (Outs Recorded), and each out is worth 0.75 points. (Remember, strikeouts are already included.)
Based on this analysis, which assumes a league average pitcher like Nelson, the Phillies are a better matchup than the Cubs, who are a better matchup than a league average offense.
One of the difficulties articulated last Friday in the comments section was how to project wins — this is a pretty simple yet effective way of doing so. Is this analysis perfect? No. There’s no such thing as a perfect projection system, which this sort of is as it aims to project the value of each matchup. That said, hopefully this helps frame the discussion when talking about the value of strikeouts in DFS versus the value of wins and run prevention. All things equal, give me a pitcher against a high-strikeout offense that can’t score. In the absence of that, I’ll gladly take a starter against a terribly anemic offense trying to support Sean O’Sullivan, even if that offense is fairly good at avoiding strikeouts.
I guess I should talk about my batters today a little too, right? OK, briefly:
- No one is stopping Arenado right now, home or road
- Tulowitzki is a decent risk hitting in the same lineup as Arenado with solid road numbers this season on a day where I don’t like many SS values
- Blackmon leads off in front of both of them and has had solid road numbers this year as well
- Rockies are still risky, though, so select them on the road at your own peril
- Trout and Pujols will face the homer-prone CC Sabathia and are solid values
No comments:
Post a Comment