(1) Elite Pitching. The top 3 guys on my list for the day – Danny Salazar, Steven Strasburg, and Chris Archer – are all about as safe as you can get for a DFS slate. They have elite K numbers, the ability to pitch deep into games, and are heavily favored to win against less-than-intimidating offenses. It's hard to imagine a good lineup today without one of these 3 guys in it, especially in 2 SP formats.
Salazar hasn't had great results up until this point, but the early stats show he's been quite unlucky with BABIP. Luckily, the Royals have been dreadful all season, and shouldn't do too much damage even if they get a bat on the ball. The Blue Jays have been perhaps even more disappointing offensively than the Royals, and are still without all-star Josh Donaldson. That makes Archer a great bet to do what he did against the Jays in April – 7 IP, 2 ER, and 8 K. This time though, I expect him to get a W as well.
I want to take an extra moment to talk about Stephen Strasburg. Strasburg has gone exactly 7 IP in every start this year, and has yet to allow more than 3 runs in a start. His recent numbers against the Phillies are astounding – From 2014-2016, he has a 2.23 ERA, a 0.87 WHIP, and 96 K in 72.2 innings. He's faced the Phillies twice already in 2017 with more of the same results, logging 16 Ks and a 3.21 ERA in 14 IP. He'll be in all of my lineups.
(2) Good Pitching. Kenta Maeda finally showed some signs of being the pitcher he was in 2016 in his last start, and has a great match up against the free-swinging Padres. His awful start to the season should have deflated his price considerably in most formats, and he might even be on your waiver wire in shallow leagues with impatient owners in season-long formats. Eduardo Rodriguez has the ability to strike out a ton of batters, and the Twins really aren't very good, but it's hard for me to fully endorse him based on his history of control issues, and the fact that the Twins are a top 10 team since the start of 2016 in BB%. That said, they do swing and miss a lot, so there's potential here.
(3) Pitching Gambles. NO matter how many times I get burnt, I feel obligated to mention that Francisco Liriano is worthy of consideration against high K% teams, particularly those like the Rays, who whiff a ton against lefties. This is the 3rd time Liriano will see this lineup in 2017. The first match up back on 4/7 was as bad as it could be – 0.1 IP, 1K, 4 BB, and 5 ER. The second match up was far more promising – 5 IP, 6 K, 4 BB, and 1 ER. You're going to get one or the other with Liriano, not inbetween. If you're a gambler, you can get big reward (or ruin your entire lineup). At some point, we have to start believing in Matt Cain, and there's no reason to believe he can't squeeze a little more magic out of that right arm against the mediocre Reds. He won't cost much, if you want to try to “punt” your 2nd SP or need a streamer in season-long.
(4) Bob's Bombers. Bob Uecker would have loved seeing the dingers guys like Eric Thames have been mashing against RHP this season. The Brew Crew has 38 HR against RHP this season, tied for most in the majors. Chad Kuhl hasn't given up many long balls this season, but did very recently get pounded by a lefty-heavy lineup at home against the Cubbies, and has allowed lefties to his a .404 wOBA in his career. The Brewers are likely to roll out monster Eric Thames, along with Jonathan Villar and Travis Shaw. Nick Franklin, the switch hitter, could also sneak into the middle of the lineup. Ryan Braun is probably out tonight, but if by some miracle he makes his way into the lineup, I'd consider rolling him as well.
(5) Other Bad Pitchers. Because I'll be spending so much on pitching tonight, I'll be looking to fill holes in my lineup across a few teams who face poor pitching. I'll mostly be looking to get hitters in against Tyler Anderson (LHP v ARI), Bronson Arroyo (RHP v SF), Phil Hughes (RHP v BOS), and Yovani Gallardo (RHP v TEX). I'll look a little at splits, but mostly at the lineups and target guys in the top 5 spaces.