Thursday, April 28, 2016

Caller ID: FanDuel Results

Last weekend, I published an article that measured the empirical impact of home plate umpires on DraftKings scoring during 2015. (Scroll down to April 23rd blurb to read it.) The caveat is that a one-season sample size may or may not produce credible results, as each ump only worked 20-40 games behind the plate over the season. But you could also say that each umpire called balls & strikes for 40-80 starting pitchers, which sounds like a better sample size. In any event, it is what it is. Hopefully, we can continue to update this analysis over 2016, now that the data is readily available.

I mused that the impact on FanDuel was likely similar, but didn’t do any analysis to support that intuition. Now I have. And while there are similarities, there are some interesting differences. In particular, the impact on hitters was greater for FanDuel than it was for DraftKings, while the impact on starting pitchers was smaller.

For example, the most hitter friendly umpires for DraftKings hitters were Manny Gonzalez (+16%) and Ryan Blakney (+12%). Those two also ranked atop the FanDuel hitter rankings, although hitters for Gonzalez achieved a 22% advantage, while hitters for Blakney improved by 15%. I don’t have a satisfying explanation for this extra performance, other than that the formulas were slightly different. This might be a good opportunity for further analysis.

On the pitching side, the converse is true. For DraftKings, the most pitcher-friendly umpires produced an extra 20%-24% in pitching points. For FanDuel, the advantage was only 14%-17%. I do have a plausible explanation for this. The DraftKings pitching formula uses a wider spectrum of factors, with points deducted for hits and walks allowed, and a much smaller reward for getting the win. The FD pitching formula has only four factors: IP, SO, ER, and Wins - and the Win component is accentuated. It’s likely that the winning pitcher is not particularly influenced by home plate umpire, while hits and walks allowed are more highly impacted.

Still, although the proportionate magnitudes of the advantages/disadvantages are different, the relative rankings are pretty highly correlated. For those who would like to see the gory details, here are the results in spreadsheet and in PDF format. The corresponding DraftKings results are here: spreadsheet and PDF.

Wednesday, April 27, 2016

Using Sabermetrics for Fantasy Baseball Part 4: Plate Discipline for Hitters

No matter how high a particular player's BABIP may be, his average will be mediocre at best if he strikes out too much. This is why fantasy owners have known for years that players like Adam Dunn, Mark Reynolds, and Chris Davis are potential drains on a fantasy team's batting average. Furthermore, players that whiff a lot tend to continue to do so - it is a very sticky trait.

In 2015, the league average K rate was 20.4%, meaning that roughly one in five MLB PAs ends in a whiff. Players that K significantly less than this have an advantage in hitting for a higher average. Players that whiff more often tend to post lower averages. This is relatively common knowledge for most fantasy owners.

Sabermetrics may be used to determine whether a given player "deserved" his K rate over a particular period, avoiding misleading data the same way BABIP is used to see through a fluky average. The first number to check is SwStr%, alternatively called whiff rate. This metric simply tracks what percentage of a batter's swings fail to make contact with a pitch. The league average is around 10%, with higher numbers indicating a proneness to K.

SwStr% tends to increase if a batter swings harder, making power hitters more susceptible to the strikeout than other players. If a player improves his strikeout rate without a corresponding improvement in SwStr%, the improvement is unlikely to stick moving forward. Likewise, a career worst strikeout rate backed by a normal SwStr% is likely to regress in the player's favor.

Further detail is offered by O-Swing%, a measure of how often a batter swings at a pitch outside of the strike zone. Generally, swinging at pitches outside of the zone is a bad idea. Batters usually want to hit "their pitch," which they never get to see if they popup a fastball over their head early in the count. In 2015, the league averaged an O-Swing% of 31.3%. Numbers significantly higher than this indicate an increased likelihood of chasing a bad pitch and striking out.

This stat is also used to examine a player's walk rate, or BB%, in much the same manner as SwStr% is used to double check K%. A strong walk rate when a player is still chasing too many pitches is not based in any repeatable skill, and will likely be normalized moving forward. Likewise, a lower walk rate paired with a career average O-Swing% indicates that the walks should come back. Fantasy owners should always care about walks even if their format does not directly reward them. Every BB is a chance to steal a base or score a run, and players that know the zone tend to hit for higher averages to boot!

Lets look at some examples of ... [click here to read the rest of the article on RotoBaller.com]

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

BvP for MVP - April 26

Josh Donaldson – 3B – Blue Jays – vs. Chris Sale
BvP: 3-for-11, 2 HR, 6 RBI
Analysis: The reigning AL MVP is matchup proof and right now he is on fire. He comes in with a 6-game hitting streak and 12 hits in his last 10 games and that includes 2 home runs. Sale owns a .191 wOBA against RHs thus far and a 1.8 ERA, but his peripherals show us that he hasn’t been perfect, sporting a 3.19 xFIP and a 3.09 SIERA. Donaldson has two dongs off of Sale already and Donaldson is making his case for the best hitter in baseball. Also, he’s likely to have lower ownership than normal due to matchup.

Chase Utley – 2B – Dodgers – vs. Tom Koehler
BvP: 6-for-15, 2 2B, 1 HR, 6 RBI, 1 SB
Analysis: Utley comes in red hot with 11 hits in his last 7 games with 3 doubles and a triple to boot. He hits atop the Dodgers’ lineup that can put up runs in bunches. Koehler owns a laughable .453 wOBA against lefties so far and has struggled mightily on the road in his career.

Miguel Cabrera – 1B – Tigers – vs. Rich Hill
BvP: 3-for-3, 1 2B, 1 HR, 2 RBI, 1 SB
Analysis: He’s alive! Miggy has returned. After receiving a day off on Sunday, Miggy was back in the lineup Monday and pelted two home runs off of the zit that is Kendall Graveman. Now he gets a lefty in Rich Hill at home where Miggy has thrived since becoming a Tiger. Hill has revived his career as pitcher, but his .357 wOBA and 40.7% hard contact against RHs is going to make life difficult for the aging lefty.

Kendrys Morales – 1B – Royals – vs. Jered Weaver
BvP: 8-for-14, 1 2B, 1 HR, 1 RBI, 4 BB
Analysis: Jered Weaver isn’t even in the stratosphere of his former self. He currently sports less than 4 K/9 while allowing 1.59 HR/9. He has a 3.12 ERA already with an ungodly xFIP of 6.23 with a 5.99 SIERA. He’s a back cyst ready to burst. The only thing going for Weaver is Angel Stadium, one of the best pitcher venues. I’ll take my chances with Kendrys Morales against his former team at a reduced rate and low ownership against an aging pitcher sporting a .453 wOBA versus lefties.

Nelson Cruz – OF – Mariners – vs. Dallas Keuchel
BvP: 7-for-14, 1 2B, 2 HR, 4 RBI, 3 BB
Analysis: I am certainly taking a chance with this pick considering Dallas Keuchel keeps the ball in the yard and has a 2.69 GB/FB rate to open the season (he’s had +3 GB/FB rates the past two seasons). However, like Donaldson, I will always play guys like Cruz against handedness of which they destroy. For Cruz, he dominates lefties and has 2 HRs off of Keuchel in 14 PAs. Cruz also is in good form and when he is seeing the ball, he too is matchup proof. Cruz has 4 multi-hit games in his last 10 and HRs in 2 of his last three ball games. Keuchel struggles on the road more than at home, so Cruz is in a solid spot with upside and likely low ownership.

. . . .

[click here to read the rest of the BvP article on DailyOverlay.com]

Hotdogphingers is a contributor for dailyoverlay.com with a journalism background. He is a veteran of season-long fantasy sports who moved into DFS nearly two years ago. His favorite daily sports are MLB, NFL, golf and college football. Follow hotdogphingers on Twitter @hotdog_phingers.

Monday, April 25, 2016

FanDuel Scoring Formula is Changing

Fanduel has announced that, effective April 27, the scoring formula will change for hitters. Until then, hitters will be awarded 3 points for each run scored and 3 points for each RBI. Beginning April 27, the run value increases to 3.2, and the RBI value increases to 3.5. The official announcement is here.

At DBD, we will adjust our point calculations to correspond to the FanDuel change. This means that historical point values for April 5-26 will reflect the formula in effect during that span, while point values for April 27 and beyond will reflect the new formula.

Saturday, April 23, 2016

Caller ID (Who’s Making the Calls?)

One of the data elements that is provided in the MLB DFS master file is the home plate umpire for each game. I figured that this might lead to some interesting analysis – and maybe some of you have already begun doing so. I recently did some limited googling for DFS analysis related to umpires and found a few articles, but not much.

I did some very preliminary analysis on the data for the full 2015 regular season (which is available – for free - in the 2015 master file.) First, I selected all umpires who worked at least 20 games behind the plate during the 2015 season. There were 83 of them. The average number of home-plate games for each ump was 28, with a range from 20 games to 38 games.

For this analysis, I decided to look only at the performance of starting pitchers and starting hitters. I used DraftKings points (DKP) as the basis for the analysis, although I suspect similar results would be generated by FanDuel points or any other similar scoring system.

My objective was to evaluate how pitchers and hitters produced with specific umpires relative to their full-season averages. As a point of reference, the 2015 average DKP/game for starting hitters was 6.94, while the average starting pitcher produced 14.16 DKP/game.

For each of the 83 selected umpires, I calculated the average differential by which a player’s DKP for that game exceeded or fell short of his full-season average. These were tallied separately for hitters and pitchers. Hitters, for example, averaged 1.11 points more in games in which Manny Gonzalez was the home plate umpire. That is 16% above average. Similarly, starting pitchers averaged 3.26 points better than average when Toby Basner was calling balls and strikes, an outperformance of about 24%.

There may be factors that explain these variances other than home plate umpire. Ballpark influences, for example, might produce some of the variation, especially if umpiring crews are not geographically diversified over the course of a season. I glanced at the distribution of home plate umpires by ballpark, and did not see any striking disparities. No umpire worked the plate in more than 3 games at Coors field, for example, and 59 different umpires worked at least one game there. (Neither Manny Gonzalez nor Toby Basner worked the plate at Coors at all in 2015. At the other ballpark extreme, Gonzalez worked twice in scoring-hostile AT&T Park in San Francisco. But Basner didn't appear there either.)

I assembled a table showing the average +/- difference in DKP (actual points minus average) for each of the 83 umpires, expressing the differences both in points and as a percent of the average. Those tables are provided both as a spreadsheet and in PDF format. A few broad observations:

  1. In general, hitting and pitching results are negatively correlated. But there are some obvious anomalies.
  2. The most favorable umps for hitters were Manny Gonzalez and Ryan Blakney. As I noted earlier, there may be other explanatory factors at play for them. But the surface stats suggest that hitters produced more than 10% above their full-year averages when those two guys were calling balls and strikes.
  3. Gonzalez and Blakney were the two most hitter-friendly umps, but neither led the pitcher-unfriendly rankings – although they were both moderately unfavorable for pitchers.
  4. The most pitcher-friendly umps were Toby Basner, Mike Muchlinski, and Ben May. Starters produced more than 20% better than their averages in the presence of those three. Hitters in those games also underperformed by 10+%, ranking them near the top of hitter-unfriendliness.
  5. I did a little investigating into differences related to righty vs lefty starters, as it seemed plausible that umpires might exhibit some tendencies that are related to pitching arm. I did find some variation – although I couldn’t rule out that much of this result was driven by randomness due to the smaller sample sizes (i.e., most umps only called balls and strikes for 10-15 southpaw starters.) So I abandoned that analysis for now.
I’ll let you digest this data for now. If these results are credible and predictable (and I suspect some disparities are symptomatic of the umpires’ idiosyncrasies, but some are simply noise), then the next step is to be able to anticipate which umpires will be working the plate in upcoming games. That will be the topic of a follow-up article.

Friday, April 22, 2016

The Big League Chu - April 22

Pitchers I’m Picking

Matt Moore – The prototypical post-hype sleeper this offseason, Matt Moore had a great spring, and it has carried over so far this season. In 3 starts so far, he’s yet to allow more than 3 runs, walk more than 2, and strike out fewer than 5. He’s got 21 Ks over 18.1 IP, which is exactly the kind of gold we’re looking for. Thanks to his long injury history and the fact that he hasn’t been a big commodity the last few seasons, he’s priced extremely well in DFS for his matchup tonight with the Yankees. As a team, the Bronx Bombers have a wOBA of .280 against lefties like Moore, the 7th worst in baseball. They don’t strike out a ton, but a 21.6 K% is high enough for this to be an enticing play. I’m using him everywhere I can.

Felix Hernandez – Most of us were a bit worried about King Felix last season thanks to some uncharacteristic rough patches, but so far in 2016 there has been nothing but smooth sailing. He’s striking guys out, not walking guys, and not giving up hits, like the King Felix of old. He’s the top pitching option for the day, and is priced as such, but I’m suggesting him here anyway for one reason – the Angels aren’t as scary as you think. Their big bats, formidable as they are, are all right-handed. King Felix has been dominant against righties his entire career, evidenced by a 24.3 K% and a .274 wOBA allowed to righty bats. In 2016, the Angels have been the worst team in the Majors against RHP with a .239 wOBA. In 50/50 or smaller leagues where you want to have a safer play, this is the place to go.

Deep League/Desperation Play – As it was last week, there aren’t a ton of great bargain options tonight worth considering based on the overall strength of the upper and middle tiers of pitching. This week, the best looking deep league play is a bit of a wildcard – knuckleballer Steven Wright. With a knuckleball pitcher, splits don’t really matter. What does matter, though, is K%, and the Astros love to swing. Wright has surprised this year in his two starts against the Blue Jays, throwing 12.2 total innings while allowing just 3 runs and striking out 11. The Astros have a similar profile to the Blue Jays in terms of hitting (lots of home runs, lots of power hitters, mostly right-handed), with one major difference – they strike out a LOT more. If Wright can get the ball to dance in Houston, he should induce a large number of strikeouts and pop-ups. His price varies from site to site, but should be fairly low. His ownership % in both DFS and season-long is really low. He’s a great streamer in your season-long leagues and a sneaky starter in your 2 pitcher DFS formats.

Pitchers I’m Picking AGAINST

Scott Kazmir and Jon Gray – A fairly obvious play, but this one is in Colorado, and neither pitcher has shown they are much of a threat this season. Kazmir has given up 10 runs in his last 2 starts, and Gray is coming off of an injury. Kazmir has shown some reverse splits since the start of 2015, but over his career has given up above-average numbers to right handed hitters. Gray, also a lefty, shows some major vulnerability to batters on the right side. Weather patterns are showing a little bit of wind blowing out at Coors, and of course, it’s Coors. Righty hitters on either team are favorable here, like DJ LeMahieu, Trevor Story, Nolan Arenado, and Mark Reynolds for the Rockies, and Justin Turner, Yasiel Puig, Yasmani Grandal, and Howie Kendrick for the Dodgers.

Zach Davies – One strategy I’ve used in the past is to pick on young pitchers. We don’t know much about Davies, in terms of what he can do in the Majors, but in the Minors, he hasn’t posted great K numbers or really done anything that I’ve seen that stands out. I’d take a look at the heart of the Phillies order as a “zag” play (a “zag” play is when you try to take a player or stack that you think will be largely unowned, giving you an edge in the larger formats if the stack hits well, since very few of your competitors will be enjoying the same success). Lefties like Odubel Herrera and Maikel Franco are ideal, and Cesar Hernandez, Ryan Howard, and Carlos Ruiz can also help you fill in spots in your line up for a very good price.

Jon Niese – The Diamondbacks have had a less than perfect start to their season. They’re just over .500 in the win column, but have dealt with a devastating injury to emerging star A.J. Pollack. I think their fortunes can turn around a bit against left-hander Jon Niese. Niese, historically, has struggled against righties and with the long ball, which plays right into the strengths of the Diamondbacks. Paul Goldschmidt is an obvious and very strong play today, along with Yasmany Tomas, Welington Castillo, Brandon Drury, and Jean Segura.

Again, feel free to hit me up on Twitter @Chuseph_Esquire if you’d like.

Scott Chu is just happy to have the chance to do this once a week. You can find him on Twitter as @Chuseph_Esquire, on Facebook at www.facebook.com/chuseph, shamelessly rooting for the Tigers or Lions (because apparently he loves having his heart ripped out on a regular basis), actually finding happiness while rooting for the MSU Spartans (MSU College of Law Alumni), or playing video games while listening to sports.

Wednesday, April 20, 2016

Text files moving to Subscription basis

I've alluded to this a few times in the past, but now it's becoming official: the accessing of various RotoGuru/DBD files in text format (i.e., CSV, SCSV, etc.) will soon become a premium service, subject to a subscription.

The primary file will be the new MLB DFS master file for 2016, including game-by-game data for each MLB player, with all sorts or information - opposing pitcher, weather conditions at game time, umpire, batting orders, DFS salaries, DFS positions, and DFS points. It is updated each morning, and also shows DFS data for the current day's games.

Text versions of several other reports will also be included in this subscription, including the daily point reports, daily BvP data, and RotoGuru sortable stats data.

Effective May 2nd, all of these text files will be available only as a premium service, subject to a one-time subscription fee of $35 for the whole 2016 season. Through May 1st, all of these files will continue to be free.

For more information on the various files available and the subscription, see this page:
RotoGuru/DBD text file subscription information.