Note: Lineup subject to change due to weather and released MLB lineups. Check back before contest lineups lock for our final lineup.
C: Wilin Rosario (COL) vs. B. Oberholtzer (COL) — $4,000
1B: Edwin Encarnacion (TOR) vs. J. Niese (NYM) — $4,800
2B: Ryan Goins (TOR) vs. J. Niese (NYM) — $2,200
3B: Josh Donaldson (TOR) vs. J. Niese (NYM) — $4,700
SS: Hidden
OF: Jose Bautista (TOR) vs. J. Niese (NYM) — $5,100
OF: Chris Colabello (TOR) vs. J. Niese (NYM) — $3,400
OF: Hidden
SP: Clayton Kershaw (LAD) vs. W. Rodriguez (TEX) — $12,900
SP: Hidden
I preach the pay for aces strategy, and on a day with many aces going I’m electing to take the priciest of them all — Kershaw! Why pay $12,900 for Kershaw when I can pay south of $11,000 for Madison Bumgarner, Felix Hernandez, or Johnny Cueto? Three reasons:
- Bumgarner, Hernandez, and Cueto have all been underwhelming in recent outings
- Bumgarner and Hernandez are facing each other
- Kershaw’s matchup couldn’t be any more perfect
With Kershaw, yes the price is steep, but he’s also the best pitcher in baseball by a fairly wide margin. His K% is 32.1. His BB% is 6.3. His SIERA is 2.36. He’s so completely dominant, and he’s facing a Rangers team that usually starts several key left-handed batters — Shin-Soo Choo, Prince Fielder, Mitch Moreland, and Joey Gallo. I’m sure a couple of them will ride the pine tonight, but that doesn’t make their lineup any better. Chris Sale went for 60 points last week. That could happen again tonight. (No, I’m not projecting 60 points, but I’d be shocked if he puts up under 30).
An expensive pitcher is going to require compromises elsewhere, but I still got that Blue Jays stack in! Admittedly I have two lineups with now that I can’t really choose between — a Blue Jays stack and a Rockies stack. Both concern me somewhat, resulting in the Risk Meter reaching 7 — but today’s a tough day for sorting the batters if you ask me. Jon Niese is a capable starter — not great but serviceable — who sort of reminds me of Mark Buehrle. Both starters allow a few runs in most outings, but they don’t get shelled all that often. Now, Niese gets shelled more than Buehrle, and if there was ever a time for that shelling to happen, it’s in this one. Donaldson is the best hitter of left-handed pitching in the entire league, and he’s a bargain at $4,700 (the same price as Nolan Arenado, mind you, further complicating my decision between the two stacks). I don’t love Encarnacion right now, but I acknowledge his 30-point potential and his reasonable price tag. Bautista is worth every penny at $5,100, and then it’s Goins (had to go cheap), who’s actually putting the bat on the ball right now and sort of serves as a second leadoff man from the team’s ninth spot in the order. The last decision came down to Colabello or Kevin Pillar, and I’m not sure which I want yet.
At catcher it’s one of those Rockies, Rosario. Against Brett Oberholtzer, I had to have him in there. He’ll probably bat fifth or sixth behind the meat of their order, and his career numbers against lefties are astounding — .327/.361/.632 with 31 HR in 418 PA. Some of that production came in years when Rosario was a better overall hitter, but the slpit between his lefty/righty production is pretty insane. Oberholtzer has some of the Dallas Keuchel magic whereby he gets a lot of weak contact and beats his peripherals (check out his 18.5% hard hit rate when the league average is about 30%) but the ball tends to move less in Coors, so maybe that neutralizes? Honestly, we’ll just have to wait and see. If Oberholtzer doesn’t have it today, there’s going to be some bombs in Coors.
Baseball Professor is sabermetric-slanted fantasy baseball blog with fresh content updated daily. Their fantasy analysts provide you with everything you need to run your team on a daily basis, including their SP Matchup Ratings, Fantasy News and Notes, and a no-fluff daily podcast (or as they call it, a Profcast). Get the fantasy info you want at www.baseballprof.com.