Last Friday, I suggested a low-priced David Phelps at home against the Braves, plus a mix of batters boasting three Astros and a super-hot Bryce Harper. Phelps pitched in 22.10 points for just $4,900, which allowed me to select a sure-thing Clayton Kershaw. Preston Tucker came through for just $2,000, and Harper put up a team-high 26.00 points (among batters). Overall this lineup scored 145.90 points and finished 768-of-28,817.
One of the things I really urge people to do is go back and audit their lineups. Ask yourself the following questions:
-
What worked?
-
What would you re-do?
-
What strategy did the tournament winners employ?
-
How did ownership rates differ among the varying contests?
It’s the last of those questions I want to touch on, because I think it’s extremely important but sometimes overlooked. Let’s work off the assumption that the greater a contests entry fee is, the better the entrants are. Sure, there are some pretty good people in the $1, $2, and $3 tournaments (I enter those every day), but there’s probably a greater concentration of successful players in the $27 tournament. Using that assumption, if there’s a player whose ownership rate is higher in a $27 contest than it is in a $3 contest, then it stands to reason that the better $27 entrants favored that player more than the $3 entrants.
I entered the Official Lineup in several different GPPs. Let’s take a moment to compare ownership rates for the selected players across the different “skill levels”:
| Player |
Cost |
$0.25 |
$1 |
$2 |
$3 |
$5 |
$27 |
| Clayton Kershaw |
$11,900 |
36.0 |
42.1 |
46.0 |
40.6 |
50.2 |
53.6 |
| David Phelps |
$4,900 |
1.9 |
2.1 |
2.2 |
2.1 |
1.9 |
2.2 |
| Jason Castro |
$3,400 |
11.1 |
13.0 |
12.8 |
11.5 |
15.1 |
13.5 |
| Paul Goldschmidt |
$5,300 |
18.3 |
17.9 |
17.5 |
17.8 |
16.6 |
16.5 |
| Jose Altuve |
$4,500 |
15.6 |
15.1 |
14.7 |
15.6 |
1.5 |
15.2 |
| Manny Machado |
$4,000 |
9.3 |
9.1 |
9.4 |
9.3 |
8.6 |
8.8 |
| Brandon Crawford |
$4,100 |
2.7 |
2.9 |
2.5 |
2.7 |
1.8 |
3.0 |
| Carlos Gomez |
$4,700 |
3.0 |
2.7 |
2.5 |
3.0 |
2.5 |
2.6 |
| Bryce Harper |
$5,200 |
19.3 |
16.4 |
1.6 |
17.4 |
15.1 |
12.5 |
| Preston Tucker |
$2,000 |
5.8 |
6.3 |
6.9 |
6.7 |
9.6 |
9.8 |
Ownership rates (in percentages) for last Friday’s Official Lineup
I chose a table over a chart just because the chart was too busy, but even without the benefit of visualization we can still draw some super high-level conclusions (with an admittedly narrow scope of just the players I picked on one day). Here are some general conclusions I’m willing to draw from this data:
Conclusion 1: Don’t Be Afraid of High-Priced SP!
In GPP strategy, the popular theory is that you should only pick players that can generate three or four times as many points per thousand spent. For a player like Kershaw at $11,900, this would mean an expectation of 35.70-47.60 points. While this is generally the proper approach, this logic is semi-flawed. Your goal isn’t to pick the 10 best values on the day. Your goal is to pick the lineup that scores the most points! Yes, you want to pick players that will provide good bang for your buck, but you do that in an attempt to maximize your team’s points total.
To use an obvious example, consider these two lineups:
-
Lineup A: Spend $100,000 and score 150 points (1.50 points per $1,000)
-
Lineup B: Spend $99,000 and score 149 points (1.51 points per $1,000)
The “efficiency” is better in the Lineup B, albeit not by much, but the end result is better in Lineup A. At the individual player level you definitely want to target players that are going to score more points for less money, but at the team level you just want to put together the team that will score the most points per $100,000, not the most points per $1,000 or per dollar.
On Friday, I liked Phelps and Tucker a lot, and they scored 22.10 and 12.00 points, respectively, combining for 34.10 points for just $6,900. That’s 4.94 points per $1,000 spent, which is better than we’re looking for. However, because of their extremely low combined cost — the average SP/OF duo is closer to $11,000 — we have around $4,000 in saved money to allocate elsewhere. Where you spend that money is heavily dependent upon the batters and pitchers available that day, but sure-thing starters that should be about 30 points in the bank are worth an $11,000-$12,000 price tag if you can find a Phelps/Tucker combination, even if the pricey SP doesn’t return the typical target ROI. This is why Kershaw’s ownership rose steadily across the increasing “skill levels” with the largest jumps at both ends of the spectrum.
Conclusion 2: It’s OK to Pass on Premium Bats
As the “skill level” increases, the ownership of Goldschmidt, Gomez, and Harper all decreased. If I had to guess, I’d say this happens for a few reasons. First, the increased willingness to spend on premium SP decreases the budget left for batters. Second, shrewd analysis of matchups opens up a lot of mid- or low-priced batters that can provide good ROI. In general, it’s probably easier to find good batter values (due to the volume of batters and the surprise starters or leadoff batters uncovered when lineups are released) than it is to find good pitcher values. That’s why I’m not surprised to see spending shift more towards pitching in higher “skill level” contests. I was able to afford Goldschmidt, Gomez, and Harper because I was one of the about 2% to risk it with Phelps and the about 7-9% to go with Tucker.
Conclusion 3: Know the Bargain Basement Values!
I don’t know why far fewer of the lower “skill level” entrants picked Tucker. Maybe they didn’t know he was starting. Maybe they knew he was starting but didn’t know who he was. Maybe they didn’t want to use such a cheap batter. Maybe it was a combination of all three. Whatever the reason, the higher “skill level” entrants identified Tucker and were rewarded for it with 12.00 points for $2,000, or six points per $1,000. When lineups come out, consider all options.
Now, all of those conclusions are extremely cursory and, as I mentioned, based on one day’s ownership rates for 10 players. Don’t take these conclusions to heart as absolutes, but consider them when you make select your lineups.
For today's lineup recommendations, see baseballprof.com
Baseball Professor is sabermetric-slanted fantasy baseball blog with fresh content updated daily. Their fantasy analysts provide you with everything you need to run your team on a daily basis, including their SP Matchup Ratings, Fantasy News and Notes, and a no-fluff daily podcast (or as they call it, a Profcast). Get the fantasy info you want at www.baseballprof.com.